KIMBERLY KEAGAN
  • HOME
  • About
  • Books
  • Puddings & Pages Club
  • ARC Request
  • Stay in Touch
  • HOME
  • About
  • Books
  • Puddings & Pages Club
  • ARC Request
  • Stay in Touch
Picture

When Love Comes

by Penny Zeller*
Published:      December 5, 2023
Series:             Wyoming Sunrise
Pages:              357
Genre:             Historical Christian Romance
Setting:            Wyoming, 1895
Picture
Kimberly's Rating (out of 5 hearts)

What happens when a heartbroken young woman leaves her hometown to visit two quirky aunts only to find her pesky childhood nemesis is a neighbor?

Charlotte Eliason promises herself never to fall in love again—not after she was cheated on by the man she expected to marry. With some encouragement from her mother, she takes the train to visit her two spinster aunts who try to throw her together with the town’s new blacksmith. However, he’s the last person she wants to spend time with.

Tobias Hallman moved to Prune Creek to establish a blacksmithing business. But his quiet life is upended when the vexing Charlotte moves to town and her meddlesome aunts keep inviting him to supper. Who can refuse a free home cooked meal?

Charlotte and Tobias forge a tentative friendship and find they get along much better now they are adults. When Tobias’s brother and sister-in-law die during an influenza outbreak, Tobias takes in their orphaned daughter. Charlotte adores the five-year-old Lanie. She also finds her defenses cracking for the blacksmith, and she vows to help Tobias do whatever it takes to keep the little girl.

I thoroughly enjoyed this story!  I liked the main characters right away and found myself rooting for them, especially Tobias—even though he'd been a terror to Charlotte as a boy. This enmity to love has a bit of a twist in that the animosity started when they were children. But honestly, who among us didn't secretly like the boy who pulled our pigtails, despite our loud protestations?

What I loved:
  • The weaving of faith throughout
  • Third book in a series but stands fine on its own.
  • Enemies to friends to more
  • Chemistry between Charlotte and Tobias
  • Secondary characters, especially the quirky aunts and Lanie, Tobias’s niece
  • The bits and pieces of history the author has researched so thoroughly.
  • Author’s notes at the end of the book
  • The cover

*You can find Penny at pennyzeller.com

Copyright © 2022-2025 Kimberly Keagan

Ventana Publishing LLC
11201 N Tatum Blvd Ste 300 # 289148

Phoenix, Arizona 85028-6039
Questions or Comments?
Site,  copyright, and privacy policy
SITE LAST UPDATED: May 15, 2025
Proudly powered by Weebly